Month: June 2023

Categories
Report

Special UK Report – Fine wine: the journey from passion asset to mainstream asset class

UK wine investment report
  • Our special report, entirely based on primary research, reveals wealth managers’ and financial advisers’ attitudes toward fine wine.
  • Almost all (96%) UK wealth managers expect demand for fine wine to increase.
  • Fine wine is ahead of watches (86%) and luxury handbags (80%) in second and third place respectively.

UK wealth managers see demand for fine wine comfortably outstripping other passion assets, such as watches, luxury handbags, and art. This is one of the findings in our special UK report, Fine Wine: The Journey from Passion Asset to Mainstream Asset Class.

Fine wine – the most in-demand passion asset

The report, based on a study conducted among 50 UK-based wealth managers and financial advisers who only deal with high-net worth clients (£100K+), revealed that fine wine will attract most demand from investors over the coming year amongst all leading passion assets. 96% expect demand to increase, of which three out of five (60%) said that it will increase “significantly”.

This placed fine wine comfortably ahead of watches (86%) and luxury handbags (80%) in second and third place respectively. Other well-established passion assets such as art (68%) and classic cars (62%) placed much lower in sixth and tenth place.

Fine wine in investment portfolios

The report found that fine wine is already featuring prominently in many wealth managers’ client portfolios. UK wealth managers and advisers estimated that over 40% of their high-net-worth (“HNW”) client base invest in fine wine with an average portfolio allocation of around 10%.

Fine wine’s growing prevalence among HNW client portfolios provides compelling evidence, if any is needed, that it has graduated to a genuine alternative asset, a highly effective portfolio diversifier, operating alongside other popular alternatives such as hedge funds, real assets, and private capital as well as mainstream assets such as fixed income and equities.

In common with other alternative assets, fine wine tends to feature more prominently in larger portfolios belonging to more sophisticated investors where there is a greater premium on diversification. Almost all respondents (98%) said that clients investing in fine wine are mainly experienced investors, with 62% saying they were “very experienced”.

Please fill in the form below to download your complimentary copy of the report.

Categories
Report

Special US Report – Fine wine: the journey from passion asset to mainstream asset class

US wine investment report
  • Our special report reveals how US wealth managers and financial advisers perceive fine wine as an investment.
  • Almost all (92%) US wealth managers expect demand for fine wine to increase.
  • Fine wine is ahead of jewelry (78%) and antique furniture (78%) in joint second.

In recent years, fine wine has grown in popularity among affluent and high-net worth individuals in the US, driven by a greater recognition of the role it can play in delivering stability, attractive returns, and diversification to investment portfolios.

To date, there has been limited research into how fine wine is perceived by the key gatekeepers to sophisticated private investors, namely wealth managers and financial advisors.

Our special US report, Fine Wine: The Journey from Passion Asset to Mainstream Asset Class, seeks to bridge this gap by drawing on independent primary research among 50 US-based wealth managers and financial advisors.

Fine wine demand to increase

Our findings revealed that fine wine will attract most demand from investors over the coming year amongst all leading passion assets, with almost all (92%) of the surveyed expecting demand to increase.

This placed fine wine comfortably ahead of jewelry (78%) and antique furniture (78%) in joint second. Other well-established passion assets such as classic cars (64%) and art (54%) placed much lower in sixth and ninth place.

Fine wine’s place in a portfolio

The report found that fine wine is already featuring prominently in many wealth managers’ client portfolios. US wealth managers and advisors estimated that almost half (45%) of their high-net-worth (“HNW”) client base invest in fine wine with an average portfolio allocation of around 13%.

Fine wine’s growing prevalence among HNW client portfolios provides compelling evidence, if any is needed, that it has graduated to a genuine alternative asset, a highly effective portfolio diversifier, operating alongside other popular alternatives such as hedge funds, real assets, and private capital as well as mainstream assets such as fixed income and equities.

The report further provides in-depth research on the most common reasons for US investors to consider fine wine, and catalysts for further growth.

Please fill in the form below to download your complimentary copy of the report.

Categories
Learn

Navigating the fine wine market: insights for savvy investors

A version of this article by WineCap’s CEO Alexander Westgarth was first published in Forbes.

  • Fine wine has been traded for millennia although its popularity as an investment is more recent.
  • The fine wine market’s stability compared to stocks make it an effective volatility smoother, preserving wealth during market downturns.
  • Investors should consider factors such as illiquidity risk, storage costs, and insurance coverage, while positioning wine as a complementary asset within a diversified portfolio.

The world of fine wine has long captivated investors with its timeless allure. Wine appreciation and collection is one of the oldest practices; the ancient Greeks, Egyptians, Phoenicians and Romans were all big traders of wine. Perhaps the first evidence of wine investment in the more traditional sense can be found in the writings of Thomas Jefferson, America’s third president. In 1787, he wrote that the 1786 vintage for top Bordeaux wines cost 1800 livres per tonneau compared to 2000 livres for the older 1783.

Today, the fine wine market is gaining popularity, not just among oenophiles; investors and wealth managers are looking to reap the benefits of this diverse asset class. New participants are eager to ensure they avoid potential pitfalls and make informed investment decisions. This article provides some of the key considerations for successful wine investing, showcasing the market’s potential at a glance.

Wine as a hedging asset

When constructing a well-rounded investment portfolio, it is crucial to consider the inclusion of fine wine as a hedging asset. Fine wine has a historical track record of retaining and increasing its value, even during periods of economic recession or financial uncertainty. Recent years are a case in point. While the world grappled with pandemics, wars and inflation, fine wine enjoyed an incline. Over the last half-decade, the average bottle of fine wine has increased in value by a notable 45%, according to the Liv-ex 1000 index.

Certain wines did exceptionally well over the pandemic. The standout players were Burgundy, Champagne and Bordeaux. At the start, fine bottles of Burgundy were selling for just under £200 (May 2020). But within two and a half years, average prices soared to over £325 (September 2022)—a return of 62%.

There are several reasons why wine tends to buffer against market shocks. Firstly, as a physical asset, it is less sensitive to inflation – just like property, gold or excellent art. Secondly, the market is private. Buyers are often high net worth or ultra-high net worth individuals, so they are wealthy and passionate. Thirdly, it is a rare and depleting asset.

The scarcity factor of fine wine makes it increasingly valuable over time. As purveyors open bottles, the demand outweighs supply and prices can soar. For instance, Domaine Leroy’s Nuits-Saint-Georges’ Aux Lavieres has experienced a remarkable 353% increase in value over the past five years, driven by its scarcity.

Wine can smooth out volatility

An excellent wine must be enjoyed slowly. In the same way, the wine market tends to move at a more gentle pace too. While stocks can sky-rocket or plummet in weeks, wine movements often take months. This can add much-needed stability to investment portfolios.

Wealth managers have harnessed the volatility-smoothing properties of wine to offset the erratic performance of other assets. Even a modest allocation of up to 10% can significantly reduce overall portfolio volatility and act as a valuable tool during market downturns. When inflation rockets, it can also help to preserve some of the wealth eroded through bonds and cash-like instruments.

Liquidity, storage and insurance considerations

Potential investors should be mindful of the illiquidity risk associated with wine investments. While the wine itself is a liquid asset, the investment tends to lack immediate liquidity. Investors should carefully assess their liquidity needs before embarking on a wine investment journey. Those who might need quick access to cash may want to include some cash-like investments like T-Bills or Bank CDs in their portfolio.

A buy-and-hold strategy typically yields the best results in wine investment. Selling too early can result in missed opportunities for substantial profits, especially when considering the maturity of the vintage. While digital platforms offer relatively quicker selling options, physical auction routes may take longer but can still deliver favorable outcomes.

Investors must also factor in the costs associated with wine investments. Unlike investing in public markets, fine wine incurs additional expenses such as secure storage and temperature control. Investors may also consider insurance, particularly when transporting wines between locations. Although these costs are generally affordable, it is advisable to research storage options, seek reviews, and negotiate insurance coverage within annual fees.

In the United Kingdom, fine wine investments often benefit from exemptions from capital gains tax. This favorable tax treatment can offset storage costs multiple times over, further enhancing the investment’s attractiveness.

Investing soberly

While the potential for substantial returns in fine wine investment is evident, it is crucial to navigate the market with prudence and awareness of potential pitfalls. Investors should maintain sufficient liquidity in their portfolios to handle unforeseen emergencies and consider the long-term costs associated with wine investments.

The key to successful wine investing lies in positioning wine as a hedging asset and volatility smoother within a broader array of assets. Although an exceptional bottle of wine holds its own allure, it should not overshadow the rest of the portfolio. Wine should be viewed as a stable and valuable component, working harmoniously with other investments to help investors achieve their long-term financial goals.

With careful consideration of market dynamics, wine’s inherent hedging properties, and a prudent approach to investment, investors can embrace the timeless elegance of fine wine while capitalising on its investment potential.

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

Categories
News

Champagne’s financial bubbles: rising costs spark concerns over affordability

Champagne
Champagne
  • Rising production costs and inflationary pressures in Champagne have raised concerns around its accessibility and its appeal to consumers.
  • Higher interest rates pose challenges for financing grape supplies, potentially eroding profit margins for smaller Champagne producers.
  • Champagne’s investment market has also been undergoing a similar shift, which has diminished its relative affordability compared to other fine wine regions.

Champagne has experienced a period of remarkable success, with a new record turnover set for the region in 2022, The Drinks Business highlighted in an article this week. However, leading figures in the region have noted that inflationary pressures and rising production costs could potentially make Champagne too expensive. This is a particular concern at the lower end of the market where fixed costs make up a larger proportion of the value of the wine and the need to keep prices affordable is more pronounced. But prices have come under pressure in the secondary market too, which has shifted its dynamics.

Champagne’s rising costs spark concerns among smaller producers

The escalating prices of grapes, along with increasing costs of labour, energy, packaging materials, and glass, have placed significant financial pressures on some Champagne houses. According to the article, the price of grapes from the 2022 harvest rose by as much as 10% compared to the much smaller 2021 vintage.

Rising interest rates, which were sitting below 1% two years ago and have now reached 3% and higher, have added extra pressure on financing grape supplies, potentially eroding profit margins of smaller producers. Meanwhile, various packaging materials, including paper, foils, cases, and glass, are up by around 40%.

The rising production costs may lead to further price increases for Champagne. This situation raises concerns around Champagne’s accessibility and its appeal to consumers. Some producers fear that higher prices could deter customers and potentially drive them towards alternative sparkling wines.

The shifting dynamics of Champagne’s investment market

The dynamics of Champagne’s secondary market have also been undergoing a clear shift. Previously, everything seemed to work in Champagne’s favour: abundant stock, strong distribution, consistent demand, and relative value compared to other fine wines.

Speculators have taken advantage of Champagne’s strengths, fuelled by a string of excellent vintages that increased demand. This has altered the traditional rules of the Champagne market, as speculators often hold onto their stock without consuming it, resulting in potential oversupply. The sustainability of rising prices in the face of a potential stock overhang can present a challenge.

Meanwhile, the rising price of Champagne has diminished its relative price advantage compared to other fine wine regions. Previously considered an affordable entry point into the world of fine wine, Champagne’s average prices now rival those of Bordeaux. For instance, the average case price of Krug Vintage Brut (£5,001) is higher than that of the First Growth Château Haut-Brion (£4,802).

Champagne vs Bordeaux

*Over the last five years, Champagne prices are up 76.8%, compared to 15.3% for Bordeaux. Champagne experienced stellar price performance between mid-2021 and the end of last year. Year-to-date, its index is down 9.1%.

Some producers have also displayed an ambition to raise prices. Notable brands, such as Philipponnat’s Clos des Goisses and Lanson’s Le Clos Lanson, have joined La Place de Bordeaux, signaling their intent to push their brands. Last year, François Pinault’s Artemis Group acquired a majority stake in Champagne Jacquesson. While this highlighted Champagne’s investment potential, it also indicated a departure from offering wines at entry-level prices.

All of this presents a complex landscape for Champagne’s future pricing and market positioning; particularly, for smaller more affordable producers, less able to spreads costs over multiple products and absorb the rising costs. Is the era of affordable Champagne over?

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

Categories
Learn

Bonds vs fine wine: what should you invest in?

  • Both bonds and fine wine can help to mitigate short-term risk in a portfolio.
  • After ten years the average bond delivers a 15% return, while fine wine – 78%.
  • Fine wine is an inflation-resistant asset, unlike bonds.
  • Bonds are generally much more liquid than fine wine.

Bonds are one of the most popular ways to invest. For decades, investment managers would opt for a strategy known as “60/40”, where 60% of the portfolio was allocated to equity and 40% to debt instruments. The idea was that the riskier equity (stocks and shares) would shield against inflation while helping to generate returns. By contrast, the more stable debt instruments (bonds and credit) would ground the portfolio and prevent it from plummeting during market downturns.

However, a lot has changed since then. Today, many experts comment that the 60/40 rule no longer applies. Instead, investors need to diversify much more to achieve more market stability. And they need to go further afield – into alternative assets – to find true inflation resistance.

In this article, we’ll compare the risk, value drivers, return, liquidity, and inflation characteristics between bonds and fine wine.

Both wine and bonds can mitigate short-term risk

Bonds come with many different risk levels. Some borrowers – like fledgling start-ups – are extremely likely to default. While there are others – like the governments of developed nations or blue-chip companies – that are almost definitely going to meet the repayments.

Occasionally investment managers will opt for extremely risky debt – known as a High Yield Bond strategy. But generally, most will allocate a greater portion of the portfolio to low-risk bonds, which tend to be rated AAA or Aaa by specialist agencies. This is usually to anchor the portfolio and help bring in stable fixed income.

Like bonds, fine wine is also generally a low-risk investment. Because the value is intrinsic, it is unlikely to plummet overnight. After all, fine wine will always be valuable. No matter what’s going on in the stock market, somebody will almost always want to buy it.

Investment managers will often add a small allocation to fine wine to help preserve wealth and mitigate risk. We have noticed that the wealthier the client, the higher the proportion tends to be. So, ultra-high net worth (UHNW) individuals and family offices generally have more fine wine in their portfolios.

The sources of value are different

While AAA bonds and fine wine may have similar risk levels, their revenue sources couldn’t be more different.

Investors make money from debt instruments like bonds by collecting the repayments from the initial sum, plus interest (the extra interest is known as “coupons”). With bonds, investors get regular revenue, which is why the asset falls under the category of “fixed income”. The repayments and coupons are usually paid quarterly.

By contrast, fine wine investors generally need to wait until they have sold the cask or bottle before they can access any returns. However, the returns are usually much more lucrative than bonds.

Wine has a stronger return profile

The average annual return of a bond is 1.6%. Usually, bonds will last for longer than a year though. Short-term bonds are around three years, mid-term is about five years and long-term is anything over a decade. Over ten years, investors gain an average of 15% returns. This means that if you invested £1,000, you could expect to get around £1,150 back.

One of the useful things about a bond is that investors should be able to clearly know how much they will get in advance. This is because the repayment terms and interest are already agreed upon, it does not depend on the ebbs and flows of market sentiment.

Like bonds, fine wine can also take some time to realise its return potential. But, on average, it’s much more profitable for investors than bonds. Figures from the Liv-ex 1000 index show that the average bottle of fine wine already brings returns of 23% after two years. After five years, that increases to 34%, and after ten to 78%. So, if you had invested £1,000, you could expect to get back £1,780%.

Liv-ex Fine Wine 1000 ten years

You can follow how specific bottles have performed over the past decade with Wine Track.

Bonds are more liquid than fine wine

There are two main ways to invest in bonds. You can buy them on the primary market and lend money directly to borrowers, or you can trade bonds on the secondary market. In the secondary market, the new buyer will then own the debt and pick up the repayments. This makes bonds quite liquid, meaning they are fairly easy to sell and turn into cash if you suddenly need the money. For publicly traded loans (rather than private debt) you should usually be able to sell a bond and expect the money in your bank account within a week.

Fine wine investors also have a primary and secondary market, but the process of trading is not usually so quick. For the best results, investors should wait until the wine matures before selling. But this can mean that the money is locked-up for months or years at a time. Some vintages, for example, can take upwards of twenty years to peak. If you sell early, you could miss out on valuable returns.

Before investing in wine, always consider your liquidity needs. It can be helpful to add-in some cash or cash-like investments into your portfolio in case you need to access funds quickly.

Fine wine is more inflation-resistant than bonds

Inflation occurs when the value of money decreases. Usually, this is because a central bank (like the Bank of England) prints more money to help the economy overcome a crisis, known as Quantitative Easing. While this measure may help to prevent a recession, sooner or later it usually needs to be reversed. When the economy is red hot, central banks normally need to hike up the interest rates to cool things down again. This can be painful for debt investors, and especially those holding long-term bonds.

Imagine that in 2019, you bought a ten-year bond to lend £1,000. At this time, the bank rate was set at 0.75%. Today (in 2023), you would still have six years left on your bond, but the bank rate has soared to 4.5%. The borrower will still be paying you the rate that was agreed in 2019. You could be paying more for your own mortgage or credit card than you’re getting back from your investment.

What’s more, the initial sum is becoming worth less by the day as high inflation of 8.7% grips the economy. If the inflation continues, by the time the bond is repaid, that £1,000 is the real value equivalent of just £740.55 today.

The downside of investing in bonds is that they don’t really protect you from inflation, especially over the long term.

Fine wine, on the other hand, is a good example of an inflation-resistant asset. Over the years, the value of precious bottles tends to keep up or even outpace Quantitative Easing.

There are many reasons for this. First and foremost, it is a physical asset like property and art, which acts like a wealth store. It is rare and depleting. Furthermore, the passionate and global market usually keeps prices at a healthy level.

The best approach is probably a mix of investments

As Nobel-prize laureate Harry Markowitz famously quipped, “Diversification is the only free lunch in finance”. This philosophy marks the cornerstone of modern portfolio theory. The idea is that you should invest in as many different revenue sources as possible to mitigate against risk. This means that for most portfolios there should be a blend of equity, debt (like bonds), alternative investments (like fine wine), real estate and some cash. Usually, the allocation to cash is about 5%.

Both bonds and fine wine have different investment characteristics. The trick is to use them in the most beneficial way to investors. For example, if you’re looking to grow your wealth over the long-term, fine wine is probably a better option. However, if you’re looking to generate regular income, investing in bonds could be a better bet.

There are interesting examples of bonds and fine wine working together within retirement portfolios. Fine wine is increasingly used as a growth generator to boost the investor’s wealth at the start of their pension journey. Meanwhile, bonds normally provide stable and regular income after the investor retires.

 

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

 

 

Categories
News

Investment opportunities in back vintage Bordeaux

Investment in Bordeaux
  • Back vintages can often offer better investment prospects than new releases.
  • Looking at Bordeaux 2022 so far, the wines have been offered at a 16% premium on last year on average; some as high as 40%.
  • Prices for physical Bordeaux have declined since the start of the campaign, making older vintages even more affordable.

With the annual En Primeur campaign in full swing, many consider the investment opportunities in Bordeaux futures. What has become clearer in recent years, however, is that back vintages can often offer better prospects than the new releases.

For many châteaux, En Primeur is no longer the cheapest time to buy a bottle, with older vintages available in the market for less. This goes against the original premise of buying futures, which was an opportunity to acquire the wines at the lowest price possible.

Price and score inflation

Although Bordeaux has experienced improvements in quality, a trend evident in critic scores inflation, the price increases have been even more noticeable.

Looking at Bordeaux 2022 so far, the wines have been offered at a 15.6% premium on last year on average; some as high as 40%. For instance, Château Rauzan Segla was released with a 40.3% increase and Château Beau-Séjour Bécot – up 37.2%.

Château Climens, which did not produce wine in 2017, 2018 and 2021 due to weather challenges, launched its 2022 with a 139.4% increase on the 2016. As a result, back vintages like 2007, 2010 and 2011 enjoyed heightened demand, which in turn pushed prices. Château Climens has become one of the best-performing Bordeaux brands so far this year, according to Wine Track, rising 39%.

Prices for physical Bordeaux decline

Not all releases have enhanced a brand’s value. Since the start of the campaign, prices for physically available Bordeaux wines have declined 1.3% on average, according to the Liv-ex Bordeaux 500 index.

This is making back vintages look especially good value, in the context of rising En Primeur prices.

Take for instance one of the most recent releases, Château Lynch-Bages 2022, which was offered at £1,280 per 12×75, up 20.8% on last year. The 2022 surpasses the price of any vintage younger than 2010. The 2019 and 2016 look particularly good value, with higher critic scores and lower prices.

Lynch-Bages

Buyers will find opportunities in old vintage Bordeaux, such as 1995 and 1996, as well as the most recent years – 2021, 2020, 2019 and 2018. The recent trilogy of greats (2018-2020) offers plenty of options, with comparable quality to the new releases and lower prices.

For instance, the average Neal Martin score for the 2022 vintage is 94.8; in comparison, his 2019 is 95.2 and 2020 – 95.1.

The campaign’s successes

As discussed in a recent article, there have been some successful En Primeur releases such as Cheval Blanc, Beychevelle, and most recently, Les Carmes Haut-Brion. These wines were offered higher than last year but still represented an attractive point of entry into the brand, and immediately enjoyed demand.

Carmes Haut-Brion

Les Carmes Haut-Brion has become a collector’s favourite as quality has improved. Until 2010, 93-points was the highest score the wine had received. The newest release achieved 98-100 points from Antonio Galloni (Vinous) and 99-100 from Yohan Castaing (Wine Advocate). Neal Martin also credited it ‘as the best Carmes the new owners have overseen’. Its average score was higher than the more expensive Ausone, Haut-Brion, Lafite Rothschild, Margaux, Mission Haut-Brion and Le Pin.

At a quarter of the price of a First Growth, and half the price of wines like Léoville-Las Cases and Palmer, the wine has demonstrated considerable potential for continued appreciation. This has been reflected in the performance of its index, which has risen 41% over the last five years, making it one of the best-performing Bordeaux properties.

The successful 2022 releases have taken into consideration existing demand for the brand, vintage quality and, most importantly, offered value compared to back vintages.

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

Categories
Learn

The pairing of old wine and new markets: demographic shifts and emerging trends

A version of this article by WineCap’s CEO Alexander Westgarth was first published in Forbes.

  • The wine investment landscape has evolved significantly, with younger, international buyers increasingly shaping the market.
  • Growing global demand has made the market more liquid, transparent and efficient.
  • New investors are exploring assets beyond traditional stocks and bonds such as wine and other collectibles.

The image of the traditional wine investor is changing. Gone are the days of gentlemen with monocles and fur coats. Today, the reality of who purchases fine wine may surprise you.

In this article, we explore the changing demographics of wine buyers and highlight modern investment trends for wealth managers looking to incorporate wine into their portfolios.

Shifting demographics: younger generations enter the market

The average wine buyer has become considerably younger in recent years. Jamie Ritchie, Head of Wine at Sotheby’s Auction House, said that in the 1990s the average wine buyer was 65. However, according to a 2021 report, only 7% of wine buyers are now over 60, while 37% are under 40. Nearly 270 millennials and Gen Zs placed the winning bid for Sotheby’s finest wines and spirits.

This shift is particularly relevant for wealth managers, as fine wine aligns well with younger investors who have long-term investment horizons. Most fine wines have potential for ageing – a good Bordeaux, for instance, can be cellared for 50+ years. This can add stability to an investment portfolio. Over the past two decades, the average price of fine wine has risen 380%, suggesting a potential for continued growth as demand increases and supply diminishes.

The liquidity challenges of wine investment

While investing in fine wine offers long-term benefits, one should not ignore the liquidity aspect. Younger investors may require quicker access to funds, which poses a challenge as wine can take time to trade. Selling wine investments prematurely may result in missing out on substantial profits. Wealth managers should, therefore, consider diversifying portfolios by combining fine wine with other liquid assets, such as cash-like securities, blue-chip stocks, and bonds. Striking the right balance between illiquid and liquid investments is key to maximising returns.

Global appeal

The international appeal of wine has grown significantly over the past two decades. According to Sotheby’s Wine & Spirits Market Report 2021 referenced earlier, North American bidders have been drawn to the market to make up nearly half of Sotheby’s new buyers.

This could be partly attributed to the power of currency. On the first day of 2021, 1 pound was worth $1.37. But by mid-December, it had zigzagged down to $1.32. As the green bills swelled in purchasing power, fine wine (usually denominated in sterling) grew increasingly tempting to U.S. investors. Today sterling continues to weaken against the dollar. As of June 7th 2023, 1 pound costs $1.24.

Additionally, Asian buyers now make up 52% of wine sales at Sotheby’s, with American investors representing 18%, and Europe (primarily split between the UK and France) accounting for the remaining 30%.

Growing global demand for wine offers some serious advantages for existing investors. As well as bringing in more potential buyers, the value of fine wine tends to rise above regional shocks. As the market base grows, the market becomes more liquid and efficient, improving price transparency.

A thirst for inflation-hedging and nostalgia

Historically, fine wine has been difficult to access. Investors needed to be deeply entrenched in elusive private markets. Owning an investment portfolio at all was generally reserved for the wealthy few.

But today, spurred by a boost in financial literacy and digital investment platforms, new groups are entering. Alongside wine, today’s digital investors are adding cultural timepieces like iconic shoes, sweaters, watches and even Legos to their portfolios. This could be partly due to nostalgia but it could also be the result of an astute investment strategy.

Historical data shows impressive returns for collectibles, with sneakers generating over 2,000% returns and Swatch timepieces delivering over 7,000%. One in-depth study found that from 1987 to 2015, Lego collectibles delivered returns of at least 11%.

Considering the anticipated high interest rates, low growth, and volatility of 2023, physical assets can serve as a hedge against inflation. While certain collectibles may be speculative, wine and art have demonstrated a history of hedging against economic downturns.

Leveraging online investment platforms and adapting to investor preferences

Wealth managers can leverage online investment platforms to access performance data, bid-ask spreads, and forecasts. They can also purchase wine directly and handle everything from storage to auctions digitally.

As the investor landscape changes, wealth managers should explore assets beyond traditional stocks and bonds. Incorporating alternative investments, such as wine, can help diversify and enhance portfolio performance. Furthermore, incorporating passion assets that resonate with younger investors, such as sustainability-focused investments and items reflecting their values, can strengthen client relationships and attract the next generation of investors.

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

Categories
News

Joseph Drouhin expands vineyard holdings to meet rising Burgundy demand

Joseph Drouhin
  • Joseph Drouhin has acquired two properties, Château de Chasselas in Saint-Véran and Rapet in Saint-Romain.
  • The expansion comes as both producers and buyers seek to find stock and value in an increasingly competitive market for Burgundy.
  • Drouhin has been a brand on the move, with some of its wines rising near 40% in value in the last year.

Joseph Drouhin expands its vineyard holdings 

Rising demand for Burgundy has fueled winery purchases and new investments. One of the most prominent producers, Maison Joseph Drouhin, has expanded its vineyard holdings with the recent acquisition of Château de Chasselas in Saint-Véran and Rapet in Saint-Romain.

Frédéric Drouhin, president of the Maison, explained that this decision was driven by increased competition and challenges in acquiring vineyards and purchasing grapes. The purchase focuses on high-quality yet more affordable areas in Burgundy – outside the main Côte d’Or villages, as both producers and buyers seek to find value in a region that has experienced significant price increases in recent years.

Just in the last five years, Burgundy fine wine prices have risen 75.7% – more than seven times the prices of the Bordeaux First Growths.

Burgundy vs Bordeaux prices

The insatiable demand and investment interest in the region have also impacted the cost of land, creating something of a vicious circle. 

The price of the latest Drouhin purchase was not disclosed.

The estates

Château de Chasselas encompasses 17.3 acres and is already a major supplier of Drouhin’s Saint-Véran wine. The property also includes small parcels in Chasselas and Beaujolais. The Rapet estate spans 19.8 acres and includes both Pinot Noir and Chardonnay vineyards in Saint-Romain, as well as small parcels in Auxey-Duresses, Pommard, and Meursault.

The debut vintage of Drouhin’s Saint-Romain wine is the 2022, while the first bottling of Saint-Véran Château de Chasselas will be the 2023 vintage, which will be released in 2024. All the newly acquired vineyards are being transitioned to organic farming practices.

With these acquisitions, Maison Joseph Drouhin owns close to 250 acres of vineyards, spanning from Chablis to Mâcon and encompassing 60 appellations. Their portfolio includes 14 Grands Crus and 20 Premier Crus. 

Drouhin’s place in Burgundy’s secondary market

Joseph Drouhin has been a Burgundy brand on the move. The brand jumped 142 places in the 2022 Power 100 rankings, thanks to its price performance. 

Four wines from the estate also ranked in the first tier of the 2021 Liv-ex Classification, which ranks the wines of the world solely by price: Montrachet Grand Cru Marquis de Laguiche, Musigny Grand Cru, Chambertin-Clos de Bèze Grand Cru, and Chambolle-Musigny Premier Cru Les Amoureuses.

The best performing Drouhin wines

In the last year alone, the best performing Joseph Drouhin wines have risen between 13% and 39%, outperforming the Burgundy 150 index. 

The biggest riser has been their Beaune Premier Cru Le Clos des Mouches Rouge, which has an average price of £1,403 per case.

You can now explore the historic performance of these wines on Wine Track. Our tool provides a clear overview of a fine wine’s track record, including critic scores, average price and investment returns. 

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

 

Categories
Learn

The role of technology in fine wine investment: From blockchain to AI

tech and wine
  • Technology has revolutionised various aspects of the wine trade, from ensuring provenance to streamlining valuations.
  • From blockchain to AI and data analytics, these advancements can improve transparency and efficiency.
  • Wine investment tools like Wine Track help investors spot opportunities and discover relative value.

In the rapidly evolving landscape of fine wine investment, technology has emerged as a transformative force, revolutionising various aspects of the industry. From verifying provenance to streamlining valuation processes, advancements such as blockchain and artificial intelligence (AI) have played a crucial role.

This article explores the impact of technology on fine wine investment, delving into blockchain-based provenance verification, AI-driven wine valuation, and digital marketplaces that are shaping the industry’s future.

Blockchain-based provenance verification

One of the significant challenges in the fine wine market is verifying the authenticity and provenance of bottles. Counterfeit wines can undermine investor confidence and erode market trust.

However, blockchain technology has emerged as a powerful tool to address this issue. By creating a decentralised and immutable ledger, blockchain allows for the transparent recording of a wine’s journey from vineyard to consumer.

Each transaction and transfer of ownership can be documented, ensuring a reliable and verifiable record of a wine’s provenance. This technology provides investors with greater confidence in the authenticity and quality of their investments.

However, applying blockchain to tangible assets like wine has some complexities. Unlike virtual transactions, the wine trade involves physical goods with unique characteristics and specific storage requirements. Bottles can be removed from cases, stored improperly, and tax status may vary, posing challenges for a fully distributed ledger system. Despite the existing challenges, blockchain holds significant potential in creating a more secure and trustworthy wine trade ecosystem.

AI-driven wine valuation

Accurate and reliable wine valuation is essential for investors seeking to make informed decisions. AI-powered tools and algorithms are transforming the wine valuation process, leveraging vast amounts of data to generate precise and timely assessments.

By analyzing factors such as vintage, producer, critic ratings, market trends, and historical sales data, AI algorithms can provide sophisticated valuation models. These models offer investors insights into the potential appreciation or depreciation of specific wines, enabling more informed investment strategies.

Digital marketplaces

Digital marketplaces have disrupted traditional fine wine trading by providing a platform that connects buyers and sellers in a transparent and efficient manner. These platforms leverage technology to facilitate secure transactions, streamline logistics, and expand the reach of the market.

Online marketplaces allow investors to access a global network of fine wines, enabling diversification and providing a more extensive selection to choose from. Additionally, these platforms often offer tools for researching wines, comparing prices, and tracking market trends, empowering investors with valuable information to make informed investment decisions.

Fine wine investment tools

One free tool that helps investors is Wine Track. Wine Track is a comprehensive fine wine index that enables investors to identify investment grade wines, spot trends and wine investment opportunities.

The tool uses daily wine price data from multiple sources, tracking over 75,000 investment grade wines. It indexes the prices of multiple vintages of a given wine, and aggregates critics’ scores, to provide a clear overview of a wine’s investment track record.

The tool also highlights the best and worst performing wines over different time periods, and includes a ‘price per point’, which is a clear indicator of relative value to help investing in wine.

Wine Track

Data analytics for market insights

Data analytics has become crucial in fine wine investment, offering investors valuable insights into market trends and patterns. By analyzing vast amounts of data from multiple sources, including auction results, critic ratings, and global demand patterns, investors can gain a deeper understanding of market dynamics.

Data-driven insights enable investors to identify emerging investment opportunities, track the performance of specific wines or regions, and make informed decisions based on historical market trends.

Technology has significantly influenced the landscape of fine wine investment, providing investors with enhanced transparency, efficiency, and analytical capabilities. Digital traceability ensures wines reach the right hands, while AI-driven wine valuation leverages data analytics to generate accurate and timely assessments, guiding investment decisions. As the wine trade continues to adapt the latest technology, investors will be able to navigate the market with greater efficiency and confidence.

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.