Tag: critic scores

Categories
News

Neal Martin awards three Bordeaux 2022 wines potential 100 points

En Primeur Neal Martin Bordeaux 2022
  • Bordeaux 2022 is predestined for long-term ageing rather than drinking young.
  • Martin found little difference between the First Growths and ‘the others’ in terms of quality.
  • He singled out Saint-Julien as an appellation to seek out.
  • Leoville Las Cases, Cheval Blanc and L’Eglise Clinet received 98-100 points.

Yesterday, Vinous published Neal Martin’s much anticipated Bordeaux 2022 report, titled “You’re unbelievable”.

Vintage observations

Martin found some ‘snow-capped peaks’, ‘show-offs whose talent cannot be denied’ as well as some ‘caveats’ in Bordeaux 2022. Like other critics, he commented on the ‘unbelievable’ freshness given the heat of the growing season.

He remarked that in 2022 ‘there is partial flattening of the hierarchical pyramid’. While ‘release prices will inevitably amplify differences in ranking, in terms of quality, there’s little difference between First Growths and “the others”,’ he observed.

On the question of Right vs Left Bank, the critic said the ‘vintage is more evenly balanced’ but singled out Saint-Julien as an appellation to watch out for, noting that ‘this is as good as it gets’.

He mentioned the wines’ higher alcohol levels compared to the 2021s, that are ‘often above 14%’ but feel ‘less blowsy than in 2018’. He also said that ‘unlike 2019 and 2020, most wines, particularly within its higher ranks, are predestined for long-term aging’.

However, he advised ‘those with a penchant for drinking Bordeaux young [to] seek out another vintage’.

In terms of buying opportunities, he argued that ‘the question is whether initial prices make any purchase worthwhile vis-à-vis other vintages currently on the market’.

Top-scoring wines

Neal Martin's top-scoring Bordeaux 2022 wines

While Martin stated that En Primeur is more than just scores, it is important to note that three wines achieved his highest in-barrel range of 98-100 points.

Cheval Blanc 2022, which was among the first releases this campaign, is ‘a wine for those serious about their Bordeaux,’ according to the critic. Vinous’ Antonio Galloni also rated it 98-100 points, noting that ‘it is shaping up to be one of the wines of vintage’. It also makes an attractive investment, with Cheval Blanc prices rising an average of 22% over the last three years.

Cheval Blanc prices and scores

For Martin, Leoville Las Cases 2022 ‘surpasses the 2018-2020 trio and […] is a ‘tour de force’’.

He described L’Eglise Clinet as ‘a wine that may leave you spellbound’.

Martin also suggested some wines from the cellar which included Brane-Cantenac, La Conseillante, Léoville Barton, Phélan-Ségur, Pichon-Baron and Vieux-Château-Certan.

You can now explore the historic performance of these wines on Wine Track. Our tool provides a clear overview of a fine wine’s track record, including critic scores, average price and investment returns.

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

Categories
News

Jancis Robinson MW releases Bordeaux 2022 scores

Bordeaux En Primeur 2022
  • Jancis Robinson MW and James Lawther MW reviewed the 2022 Bordeaux vintage.
  • Both critics found the reds to be extremely impressive, with surprising freshness.
  • Mouton Rothschild, Lafite Rothschild, Cheval Blanc and Pétrus received the highest scores.

Jancis Robinson MW and James Lawther MW reviewed the 2022 Bordeaux vintage and released a series of articles, covering the whites, red-bank and left-bank reds.

Both critics found the wines to be ‘extremely impressive’, with ‘amazing freshness’ given the hot and dry growing season.

In terms of the En Primeur tastings, Jancis remarked on the ‘record number of visitors’, with ‘Americans and Asians back in force’. According to her, the numbers at the UGC tastings were ‘even higher than in spring 2019, when the 2018 vintage was presented almost a year before pandemic lockdowns’.

This gives greater confidence in the success of the En Primeur campaign, which commenced last week.

Left-bank reds

According to the report, the 2022 harvest was the earliest on record, with most of the Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot on the left bank picked before the end of September. Despite the early harvest, the grapes’ maturity reached optimal levels. The sugar levels were similar to those found in recent years, while the phenolic ripeness was comparable to or even higher than previous vintages.

Alcohol levels on the left bank were on the high side, with 14% to 14.5% being a regular occurrence. However, the wines were often balanced with freshness.

Lawther wrote that he ‘found the characteristics of most of the appellations respected’, with Margaux being more varied.

Right-bank reds

According to Robinson, Merlot did exceptionally well in 2022, with high sugar levels, deep color and ‘no shortage of tannins for a long life lurking below the alluring surface’.

Lawther also proclaimed the grape variety to be ‘the star of the vintage’. He added that ‘Cabernet Franc was also successful on the right bank in 2022 adding colour, floral fragrance, freshness and length’. The critic claimed that ‘combined with Merlot it has produced some stunning wines, even away from the limestone plateau – witness Cheval Blanc, one of the wines of the vintage’.

White wines

The hot and dry growing season led to lower acidity levels in the whites, which translated to lack of freshness in some. Robinson further revealed that Sauvignon Blanc and Sémillon were picked earlier than ever before since Bordeaux University records began. Domaine de Chevalier Blanc stood out among the dry whites, while Château Suduiraut received the highest score of 18+ points among the Sauternes.

Top-scoring wines

The First Growth Château Mouton Rothschild topped the list of the highest-scoring wines from the 2022 vintage. Lawther described the palate as ‘truly amazing’ and questioned if this isn’t ‘a modern 1986’.

Château Lafite Rothschild, Château Cheval Blanc and Pétrus followed with 18.5-points.

So far, Lafite and Cheval Blanc have been two of the favourite wines of major critics, also boasting potential 100-points from Jeff Leve, Jean-Marc Quarin, and James Suckling.

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

Categories
News

Wine Advocate’s top-scoring Bordeaux 2022 wines

Wine Advocate Bordeaux 2022 - Château Canon
  • Bordeaux 2022 is a vintage of ‘potential greatness’ but also ‘heterogeneity’, according to the Wine Advocate’s En Primeur report.
  • The reviewers, William Kelley and Yohan Castaing, found potential for perfection in eight wines, and included a list of En Primeur recommendations.
  • Kelley noted that the second wines ‘merit more serious consideration than usual this year’.

Potential greatness and heterogeneity

During the En Primeur trade tastings last week, and following James Suckling’s report, another major publication released its assessment of the 2022 Bordeaux vintage – Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate. William Kelley and Yohan Castaing reviewed 459 wines ‘after several weeks of intensive tasting and hundreds of visits to wineries’.

The critics found ‘potential greatness’ in this vintage that has surprised many, but also ‘heterogeneity’.

Kelley explained that ‘Bordeaux has produced some monumental wines in 2022, but unlike many of the great vintages of the 20th century, the year was not a rising tide that raised all boats’.

He added that ‘at its best, this is a vintage of remarkable concentration, energy and harmony’. According to him, ‘the accumulated experience of 2015, 2018, 2019 and 2020 meant that intelligent winemakers were ready to harvest at the right time, a choice of decisive importance’. However, he noted that ‘the less-successful wines are jammy, astringent and rustic’.

The vintage heterogeneity means that buyers will have to be selective; 2022 ‘is not a year to buy blind,’ the critic argued.

Top-scoring wines

The critics found potential for perfection in eight wines, with Canon, Les Carmes Haut-Brion and Montrose coming on top (99-100 points).

Among the three, Les Carmes Haut-Brion has been the best performing investment wine over the last five years, up 56%, while also having the lowest average case price. Castaing singled it out as ‘a strong candidate for the title of wine of the vintage’.

One First Growth, Château Latour, was also among contenders for perfection, although the wine is not released En Primeur. Meanwhile, Château Mouton Rothschild, received 96-99 points. Kelley called it ‘a brilliant wine that likely sits somewhere between the 2019 and 2020 in quality’.

Kelley also noted that second wines ‘merit more serious consideration than usual this year’. In 2022, they ‘often exhibit similar structure and texture to their grand vin counterparts’.

Apart from their top-scoring wines, the critics made a list of En Primeur recommendations to buy, which included Branaire-Ducru and Langoa Barton.

En Primeur pricing

A great vintage usually translates to expensive releases.

However, Kelley suggested that there were grounds ‘for optimism with regard to pricing this year,’ if the chateaux take into account the global economic uncertainty and the state of the secondary market.

He remarked that ‘it is not always necessary to purchase great Bordeaux as futures,’ as sometimes older vintages might represent better value today.

To spot the best value opportunities and explore the historic performance of any fine wine brand, visit Wine Track. Our tool provides a clear overview of a fine wine’s track record, including critic scores, average price and investment returns.

 

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.

Categories
News

James Suckling releases Bordeaux 2022 report

‘A new benchmark’

James Suckling has released his report on the Bordeaux 2022 vintage ahead of the upcoming En Primeur campaign. The critic claimed that in the 40 years he has tasted Bordeaux in-barrel, he had ‘never come across anything like the 2022 vintage’.

2022 will stay in memory as one of the hottest years on record, featuring severe droughts and heatwaves. Despite the challenges, Suckling suggested that 2022 ‘gives us hope that both man and nature can adapt to these circumstance and produce outstanding wines, both red and white’.

He further observed that dryness and heat no longer mean bold ripeness in the resultant wines. Most winemakers have prioritised freshness and lower alcohol, ‘picking their grapes at optimal ripeness, with this “al dente” fruit giving a crunchy and clean character to the wines, with fine yet structured tannins’.

Suckling found the young wines to be ‘dynamic and fascinating’ and noted that ‘there was high quality from top to bottom’ – a sign of a great vintage.

Top-scoring wines

Suckling found nine candidates for perfection in Bordeaux 2022, awarding them a barrel range of 99-100 points.

Cheval Blanc stood out as his potential ‘wine of the vintage’, which ‘soars to new heights with its brightness and weightlessness’.

The critic was also full of praise for two Sauternes from Château Lafaurie-Peyraguey, calling the Crème du Tête ‘magical. The new 1929?’

Only one First Growth made the list, Château Lafite Rothschild, which Suckling described as ‘a classical Lafite that reminds me of something like the 1986 […] but it’s so today with its purity and precision’.

A white wine also featured among the top-scoring – Pavillon Blanc du Château Margaux. According to him, this ‘feels like a great Montrachet’ and is ‘one for the cellar’.

The question of pricing

Suckling’s verdict on the 2022 vintage is that the quality of the wines is ‘exceptional’ but ultimately ‘the market will decide’ the success of the new releases. ‘High interest rates, volatile stock prices and recent bank failures’ are some of the factors that will influence purchasing of young Bordeaux.

While the excitement of the new is guaranteed, high release prices might make older vintages look more attractive – especially if they offer value, and faster returns on investment.

 

WineCap’s independent market analysis showcases the value of portfolio diversification and the stability offered by investing in wine. Speak to one of our wine investment experts and start building your portfolio. Schedule your free consultation today.